What Rory Sutherland’s Alchemy Taught Me About Anxiety

Speeding up from 70 to 80mph on the motorway saves you less than a minute for every ten miles. It also sharply raises your risk of a serious crash. So why do so many of us do it?
That question comes from Rory Sutherland, and his book Alchemy has shaped how I think about my clients more than most books written by therapists. Sutherland works in advertising, not mental health. But his ideas point to something fundamental about how humans think. I don’t believe we can understand ourselves, or our anxiety, without it.
What Rory Sutherland’s Alchemy gets right about us
We like to think we are rational people with inconvenient feelings. Sutherland argues it is mostly the other way round. He calls it psycho-logic. Perception, meaning, status and feeling drive most of what we do. Logic usually arrives afterwards, to explain a decision we have already made.
His best-known example is the Eurostar. Huge sums were spent making the journey a little faster. Sutherland’s point was that you could spend a tiny fraction of that on better Wi-Fi and a free glass of champagne, and passengers would be happier. They might even want the journey to last longer. The time on the train didn’t need to change. The experience of it did.
The speeding example works the same way. Going from 20 to 30mph saves ten minutes on every ten miles. Going from 70 to 80 saves less than a minute, yet it feels like the bigger gain. Our sense of speed in miles per hour fools us. If dashboards showed minutes per ten miles, nobody would bother pushing past 70. Risking your life to save a few seconds seems pretty bloody insane to me. The behaviour feels logical. It just isn’t.
What I take from Sutherland is this. If you start with the wrong model of people, their behaviour makes no sense. He doesn’t get distracted by the behaviour itself. He asks a better question: what is this behaviour telling us? Who is it really working for? That is the question I bring into the therapy room.
Where does anxiety come from?
Anxiety doesn’t spring out of the blue. It comes from somewhere.
The medical model has its place. It helps us diagnose and treat, and for many people that support is essential. But naming anxiety and treating how it feels is not the same as understanding where it comes from.
My work is about the roots. When someone tells me they can’t stop worrying, or can’t switch off, or keep doing the very thing they know isn’t good for them, I don’t see a fault to be fixed. I see behaviour that is doing a job. It is working for something, often something old.
The overworker who can’t rest may still be earning the approval of a parent from thirty years ago. The person who keeps the peace at all costs may still be protecting a child who learned that conflict wasn’t safe. Against what they say they want now, the behaviour looks self-defeating. Once you see who it is really serving, it makes complete sense.
No Cluedo moment
Unfortunately, it is never a clear, easy picture. There is no Cluedo moment. It is never Mrs Green with the candlestick in the ballroom. And the answer rarely looks like a neat watercolour of a sunny afternoon.
The understanding my clients leave with looks far more like a messy work of art. Even something as simple-sounding as “I’m struggling with stress at work” has so many threads running through it: our parents, our upbringing, our friends, our traumas, our relationships, our health, our kids, our finances, our work and career, our environment, the stresses of daily life, politics, wars, illness, death, and joy.
That isn’t a failure to find the answer. That is the answer. We are shaped by all of it, at once.
Selective attention and your inner critic
How we think, and how we talk to ourselves, changes how we feel. Here’s a simple exercise to show you how.
Next time you leave the house, tell yourself: “Now I’m only going to notice what I can hear.” Or: “I’m going to pick out everything that’s red.”
Notice what happens. Suddenly there’s a bird you hadn’t heard, or a car alarm that seemed not to be there a moment ago. Red is everywhere. Psychologists call this selective attention. Stay with one sense and the world comes into sharp focus, because the mind starts selecting for what you’ve told it to look for.
Now imagine the voice doing the selecting is your inner critic. Negative self-talk doesn’t just make you feel bad. It changes what you notice, and so what the world seems to be. Look for proof that you’re failing and you’ll find it everywhere, just like the red on your walk.
That is exactly what Sutherland is challenging. We think we’re logical, rational beings. If we can get something as simple as driving that wrong, imagine what our inner critic is getting wrong about us.
What is your behaviour telling you?
Sutherland taught me to stop arguing with behaviour and start listening to it. The same is true of anxiety. It is not random, and it is not simply a malfunction. It is telling you something about where you have come from and what you have had to protect.
Understanding that won’t give you a tidy picture. But it is where real change begins: not in trying to think your way out of how you feel, but in finally understanding why you feel it.
So next time you catch yourself doing the thing you swore you wouldn’t, don’t ask what’s wrong with you. Ask who it’s working for.
Hear when the book is out
This is the question at the heart of the book I’m writing on anxiety. Leave your name and email and I’ll let you know when it’s out.
November 18, 2026










